Mr Verse - 2024-12-24
Dr. Sabine Hossenfelder is a popular science communicator, with often controversial views. In this video, I have attempted to take a critical look at the rise of Sabine, her involvement in string theory wars, recent controversy, and expert opinions. Timestamps: 0:00 - 1:14 Intro 1:14 - 4:08 Sabine's disappointment with Academia. 4:09 - 8:15 String theory wars and Sabine's entry into the Blogging world 8:16 - 8:42 Sabine's entry on YouTube 8:43 - 9:47 The Good side of her videos 9:48 - 11:24 Sabine Vs Prof. Dave 11:25 - 15:07 When Sabine gets worse 15:08 - 16:27 The fallacy of Sabine 16:28 - 18:05 Penrose Vs Sabine 18:06- 21:02 Tim Maudline Vs Sabine on Superdeterminism 21:03 - 21:39 What to make of this? Video links: Sabine's criticism of academia and current science status: https://youtu.be/gMOjD_Lt8qY?si=yhKMfhgwRQ6yTL9i https://youtu.be/HQVF0Yu7X24?si=rDdb4PUtjJYdAanT https://youtu.be/QtxjatbVb7M?si=3-IJruVg_Gz2pSQw https://youtu.be/LKiBlGDfRU8?si=OZc1dWPgl7VZXc3O https://youtu.be/cBIvSGLkwJY?si=tUDFYHwHU_cv7csZ Professor Dave's criticisms: https://youtu.be/6P_tceoHUH4?si=_dbkN6hZj3jgKOzo https://youtu.be/70vYj1KPyT4?si=pjqiZHC6SWtaw5aI Sabine's lecture in Munich https://youtu.be/4ERVKSH2xqY?si=-dpRBBHE-abpn4W9 Sabine's videos about Information paradox https://youtu.be/DHR-ggwafO8?si=xRPkZYTublhyXoE_ https://youtu.be/mqLM3JYUByM?si=2YSKG9RajUt-LxDs https://youtu.be/50bcjqEJuoc?si=5Yrv4D9ZgEmm1Y13 https://youtu.be/5rtqVFfwE_A?si=QOIhQB3RtXc2o_Yx Penrose reaction to Sabine's criticism https://youtu.be/foq4nVAwEao?si=_MMIZVmz1CYH4_Tg Tim Maudlin's reaction to Sabine's criticism https://youtu.be/fU1bs5o3nss?si=GMxrlmQHBqT5KxQV Sabine's video on Superdeterminism https://youtu.be/ytyjgIyegDI?si=qPNhIGJdGXaKoL1e